Mother slams her niece for giving her child the same name as her baby

Mother is furious to learn a close relative has given her newborn the SAME name as her own four-week-old daughter – so is she over-reacting?

  • Mumsnet user said her niece had given her baby the same name as her little girl  
  • Said she gave birth to her daughter four weeks before niece’s baby arrived
  • Told fellow parents on the Mumsnet forum: ‘I’m a bit hurt, tbh’  

A British mother has told of her ‘hurt’ at learning her niece has given her new baby daughter the same name as her own four-week-old daughter.  

Writing under the handle ‘GreyEyed’ on parenting site Mumsnet, the new mother explained she felt hurt by her niece’s decision to give her daughter the same name – even though she used a shortened version.

She said that while she would be putting the longer version of the name – which she didn’t disclose – on her daughter’s birth certificate, ‘I’m a bit hurt tbh’. 

Her dilemma received a mixed response on the parenting forum, with some pointing out that ‘no-one has a monopoly on names’, while others confessed they’d be ‘fuming too’ in the same situation.  

A woman took to Mumsnet to ask for advice on her niece naming her daughter the same as her 4-weeks-old baby (file image) 

The woman outlined in her post on Mumsnet that she felt hurt by her niece’s decision to have the same name for her baby who was born 4 weeks after her own 

‘My daughter was born 4 weeks ago (still in hospital) as she arrived premature,’ she wrote.

‘Niece gave birth yesterday morning and named her the same name (although I’m putting a long version on the BC). I’m a bit hurt tbh. AIBU?’ 

Her post prompted a stream of replies from fellow users, many of whom told her it was unreasonable to be annoyed as ‘no-one has a monopoly on names’ – particularly if it’s an especially popular one. 


  • ‘Waiting 48 hours to see my photos’: Nostalgic millennials…


    Camilla keeps her cool! Duchess dresses in a floaty white…

Share this article

‘Each child will have a friend of the same name when they get to nursery & school,’ one Mumsnet user pointed out. 

‘There’s nothing wrong with a name appearing multiple times in a family tree. Many families do it deliberately. 

‘The comparisons between a full term baby and preemy baby would be exactly the same whatever the babies’ names.’ 

Another wrote: ‘It depends if the name is something like Olivia or something like Guinevere. If it’s a very popular name, statistically, then I don’t think you can be too upset about it.’ 

A flood of responses to the Mumsnet thread argued it’s unreasonable to expect someone to name their child something different to keep the mother happy 

Others sympathized with the new mother and agreed they would be equally as annoyed if a family member named their child the same as their baby.

A user speaking under the handle ‘WallisFrizz’ claimed she would be annoyed as the child were born close to each other and not generations apart.

She said: ‘It would annoy me as they were born so close together. I’d think ‘really of all the names in the world you had to pick the exact same one as my dc within weeks of me naming it?!’ If they were a generation apart (as I though you were going to say) wouldn’t bother me.’

Another added: ‘This would absolutely irritate me. Yes of course no owns a name blah blah but seriously where’s the originality in using a very new baby’s name who you will see frequently. 

‘Also a baby who is still in hospital. A bit off I think. Also she could at least have told you before the name announcement. I presume she didn’t?’

Others claimed they would also be hurt if a family member chose the same name for their child as one they chose just weeks earlier 

A Mumsnet user who felt the woman with the dilemma was overreacting wrote: ‘Congratulations on your new baby. I think people overreact to ‘same’ names, tbh. Imagine it was you who had picked out a name for your baby months ago, kept it quiet and then ‘bam’, a family member or friend has a baby a new days or weeks before you and use ‘your’ name!

‘They didn’t know you’d planned to use the same name; you didn’t know they’d planned to use the name. Are you really going to tell me you would happily shrug and hit the baby name lists again? Or would you go with the name you had picked out, thought about, practiced saying in your head…? Let it go.’

Another added: ‘She could have had that name picked out way before she even knew you were pregnant and from her view you ‘took’ her name. 

‘I think it’s actually quite sweet that they’ll have a namesake buddy in the family.’ 

A number of contributors to the thread urged the mother to consider that perhaps her niece had chosen the name earlier 

Source: Read Full Article